Drunk Driving Survey Raises Hackles

Feb 25, 2014 | Auto Accidents

A driver in Reading, Pa., has filed a lawsuit accusing the city, its police chief and a nonprofit research center of violating his constitutional rights after he was waved him off the road into a parking lot and asked about his drug and alcohol use. Surveyors working for the research group also asked for a mouth swab to test him for impairing substances like alcohol and prescription drugs.

The motorist is among thousands of Americans who have been pulled off the road and surveyed about drunk and drugged driving by contractors for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. The public outcry about the survey’s intrusiveness has traffic safety officials and advocates defending the research as a valuable, lifesaving policy tool.

In 2007, the highway safety agency faced concerns about a Maryland-based contractor that collected survey data in an aggressive manner and tested survey participants with a passive alcohol detection device without their informed consent.

The National Roadside Survey of Alcohol and Drugged Driving is a nationwide snapshot of impaired driving that the agency has been conducting since the early 1970s. This time around, contractors have offered participants money in exchange for blood and saliva samples for alcohol and drug testing, and the results are supposed to be entirely anonymous. One woman told the Associated Press that her cooperation was voluntary and earned her “an easy $65.”

But critics say the survey tramples civil liberties because motorists are pulled off the highway at imposing roadblocks, often manned by law enforcement, and feel pressured into complying with requests for blood and saliva samples.

The 2013-2014 survey, which is nearly complete, first made headlines near Dallas/Fort Worth. The police chief in Ft. Worth apologized to the public for his department’s participation in a November roadblock that made drivers feel pressured, bewildered, and angry, NBC 5 in Fort Worth reported. The chief said citizen outcry over the survey was merited, and he promised not to engage in any future federal surveys that would violate public trust with the police.

Advocates for the survey include Mothers Against Drunk Driving and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Both organizations are invested in reducing drunk and drugged driving accidents and deaths nationwide. The president of the Insurance Institute said the survey is a critical component of efforts to prevent impaired driving.

Geoff McDonald and Associates: 804-888-8888.


No Fees Unless We Win

    How Are Truck Accidents Different From Car Accidents in Virginia?

    Power trucking accidents are one of the most dangerous types of road accidents, and they differ significantly from car accidents in several ways. The most apparent difference between a truck and a car is their size and weight. Trucks are much bigger and heavier than...

    What to Do if You’re Hurt in a Virginia Multi-Vehicle Crash

    Any car accident has the potential to cause catastrophic injuries and property damage, and multi-vehicle accidents can dramatically increase those risks.  Multiple-vehicle accidents involve three or more vehicles, which also complicates determining fault and...

    How Do I Know If I Have a Valid Truck Accident Case in Virginia?

    Truck accidents are some of the deadliest vehicle accidents that occur across Virginia, especially when commercial trucks collide with smaller vehicles. If you or a loved one suffered injuries in a truck collision, you may ask, “Do I have a valid truck accident case?”...

    Is It Illegal to Tailgate Behind another Car in Virginia?

    Following too closely in Virginia is a traffic infraction punishable by a fine beginning at $81. Tailgating in Virginia is not only a moving traffic violation that could result in demerit points on your driver’s license, but is also dangerous to drivers and passengers...

    Our Case Results

    Industrial Plant Accident

    Attorneys for the Plaintiff: Jeffrey A. Breit and Justin M. Sheldon Our client was killed in an industrial accident when an unauthorized worker was operating an overhead crane and pinned our client between…

    Rear-End Crash

    Our client suffered a traumatic brain injury, facial trauma, a dislocated hip and severe abdominal trauma when she was rear-ended at a traffic light by a tractor trailer. Suit was commenced shortly after…

    Assault of Log Truck Driver

    Attorneys for the Plaintiff: Geoffrey R. McDonald, Frank H. Hupfl, Justin M. Sheldon.
    Our client suffered a traumatic brain injury after being assaulted and knocked to the ground while fueling his logging…

    Drunk Driving Crash

    Our client suffered neck/head trauma and a broken wrist after his vehicle was struck by a drunk driver while he was stopped at a traffic light. Upon rejection of a settlement offer of $325,000, our litigation…

    Rear-End Collision

    Attorneys for the Plaintiff: Justin M. Sheldon and Geoff R. McDonald, Richmond
    GMA’s client was injured as a result of a rear-end collision in the greater Richmond area. The crash occurred a little after…

    Client Reviews

    Cheryl and Rich were wonderful and patient with me throughout the case. All of my questions were answered. They really helped me through this tough time and made sure to let me know what was going on. I really thank Geoff…

    Troy Saxby

    My experience with GMA staff was first rate. They always represented in a professional way and made sure I had everything as far as paperwork. Kara and Theo made sure to answer all my questions, was always available and so…

    Shirley Brown

    Geoff McDonald & Associates is the team that you want on the field if you’re in need of top notch legal defense! Mr. Taj Henley demonstrated true customer service skills and his expertise made me feel comfortable throughout the…

    Julian Reeves

    Geoff McDonald & Associates: Thank you Taj Henley for all of your hard work and dedication! Very expeditious in my case and I was very satisfied with my settlement. Will recommend to all my friends and family!

    Shareema Williams

    Geoff is number one in my book and I especially appreciate the support of Mr Henley

    Ebony Conwell

    I was so pleased with the knowledge and support from Mr. Taj Henley

    Kideem Frierson

    Thank you Geoff McDonald &Associates. A special thank you to Mr. Taj Henley

    Denise Conwell

    Mr. Taj Henley displays exceptional professionalism for Geoff McDonald & Associates, along with commendable communication skills and customer service. By his work ethic and commitment to the people he serves his value to any…

    Justin Fitzgerald